See how we helped Cameo scale paid revenue by 113% while improving efficeincy by 30%.
Helping Cameo Scale Paid Revenue 113% While Improving Efficiency 30%
NoGood has been amazing to work with since day one. They've really taken the time to understand our business, the creative has been leveled up every step of the way, and our channels have been more efficient across the board.
Overview
Founded by Steven Galanis, Martin Blencowe, and Devon Townsend, Cameo is a venture-backed platform revolutionizing how fans connect with celebrities and public figures.
While traditional fan experiences have been limited to distant interactions, Cameo created a marketplace bringing personalized video messages directly from thousands of celebrities to fans worldwide. Through the app, people can request custom shoutouts, pep talks, and special occasion messages from athletes, actors, musicians, and influencers. This made once-impossible personal connections accessible to everyone.
The Challenge
- Cameo’s explosive pandemic growth had cooled as consumers returned to in-person experiences, creating downward pressure on bookings and revenue.
- No access to total business data meant optimizing paid channels without visibility into overall platform performance, requiring constant stakeholder alignment.
- Onboarded just 3 weeks before Mother’s Day, Cameo’s highest-revenue period, with no historical data or established creative assets.
- Limited initial creative inventory and no established production pipeline risked audience saturation and performance degradation as spend scaled.
- Business heavily reliant on seasonal peaks (Mother’s Day, Holidays) created risk of revenue volatility and limited sustainable year-round growth.
- Gift-giving purchase behavior (buying for others) obscured true customer journey tracking and made persona validation more challenging than traditional DTC models.
Services
How We Did It
Conducted competitive analysis, persona mapping, and paid account audit to build comprehensive growth strategy. Identified Gift Giver persona as highest-value target and aligned stakeholders on Mother’s Day as critical first activation to validate strategy.
Launched gift-focused messaging with emotional reaction creative targeting millennials and Gen X. Validated core persona strategy despite compressed timeline. Established creative workflows and identified need for longer lead times on future tentpoles.
Built athlete-specific creative with NFL talent and fantasy football messaging, launching 2 weeks pre-draft season. Leveraged sports gifting use case with UGC-style content. Delivered strongest efficiency period of entire partnership.
Shifted from tentpole-dependent to scalable evergreen growth. Expanded non-brand SEM keywords and launched “Gift Pyramid” creative, which became top performer across all channels for 6+ months. Built systematic testing framework.
Pre-loaded 4 weeks of holiday creative in early November, enabling aggressive spend scaling through peak season. Deployed ASC+ campaigns for algorithmic optimization and maintained daily client check-ins to validate business impact.
Strategically phased out holiday assets while transitioning to evergreen winners. Sustained 70%+ of peak-season efficiency during off-peak period, proving year-round growth model vs. tentpole-dependent spikes.
Results
From May through year-end, we scaled paid investment 55% while improving ROAS 30%. Meta revenue grew 113% to $4.9M, TikTok launched as net-new channel driving $481K in H2.
Meta’s Advantage+ paired with Cameo’s strong conversion signal created self-optimizing audiences that scaled efficiently. Consolidated account structure improved algorithmic learning, delivering 52% higher conversion rates.
Creative testing proved humor outperformed wholesome messaging by 21% ROAS. “Gift Pyramid” sustained top performance for 6+ months. Creative diversity and velocity were non-negotiable for sustained efficiency at scale.
Performance Visualized

Top Creative Performers


Squad
Theano Dimitrakis
Sr. Growth Strategist
Kristen Montana
Growth Strategist
Cormac Beeler
Paid Social Manager
Seif El-Banhawy
Paid SEM Manager
Iris Xie
Designer
Islam Elnabawy
Growth Engineer
